Blue Hill Tavern in Baltimore

Blue Hill Tavern in Baltimore
4 / 5
50 reviews

1431 John St, Baltimore, MD 21217-4268, Baltimore

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Cafe
Features
  • Takeout
  • Reservations
  • Outdoor Seating
  • Seating
Good for
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

7:00 am

Wednesday

7:00 am

Friday

7:00 am

Sunday

7:00 am

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Blue Hill Tavern
KK
Kit Koppelia
google
04.19.2024
4/5

Oh so delicious! The tamale cakes are wonderful and I got the London fog which was also so good. Layout of the restaurant could be better but there's only so much you can do in a rowhome. Definitely worth the cramp space!

Blue Hill Tavern
RC
Russell Conwell Walker Jr
google
09.10.2018
5/5

This place is a real jewel in Baltimore City. I was sharing a quesadilla with a coworker from this restaurant previously. So I decided that on my lunch break to drop in myself. I had a turkey burger and some fries. The toppings were so fresh and the portion size was huge. I really like the fact that they are environmentally conscious and recycle. In a few block radius there aren't that many food choices in this area but this is a real treat. I will continue to visit this establishment.

Blue Hill Tavern
PL
Patricia Leach
google
08.08.2018
4/5

Was packed for the lunch time, so popular in the neighborhood. Sandwich was hugh!

Blue Hill Tavern
io
israel olorundare
google
05.09.2018
5/5

Great place to eat and just chill with friends. Their burgers are noteworthy. A little pricey. It's about a $$ on the price scale. Worth a visit. Enjoy

Blue Hill Tavern
DN
Daniel Ng
google
05.04.2018
5/5

On the Hill Cafe is the real deal... clearly! As one of their many return customers, I feel compelled to share that I find their food delicious, menu inspired, service friendly and ambience peaceful. It is a rare moment when you are successfully tempted to order multiple items and smile due to the absence of buyer's remorse! Carry on, please.

Blue Hill Tavern
SB
Scott Berry
google
05.02.2018
4/5

The burger I had was really good. The fries would have been better if they had been hot.

Blue Hill Tavern
SD
Susan Davis
google
05.01.2018
5/5

Great place to eat and just relax with friends. Their burgers are noteworthy. A little pricey. Worth a visit. Enjoy

Blue Hill Tavern
JN
John Nagata
google
05.01.2018
5/5

This spot obviously knows how to satisfy their customers. Constantly with a very kind demeanor. The food is conveniently priced, always delightful and clean.

Blue Hill Tavern
WG
Will Gallagher
google
04.11.2018
5/5

Oh my the burrito I got was to die for. Excellent food selection. I love that this is a farm to table restaurant. I see some negative reviews about the staff which definitely wasn't my experience. I will be back soon to try more and will update my review if my experience is vastly different. At the very least it is a really cute cafe, clearly popular since you have to fight for a table and the food is delicious!

Blue Hill Tavern
SI
Steve Iannelli
google
03.21.2018
5/5

If you want to support your local business, this is the place to go. The burgers are REALLY GOOD and the pork sandwich, "the Mosher", is comparable to a pork sandwich you'd get in Philly. Prices are just a bit high but it's in a nice neighborhood so what can you expect.

Blue Hill Tavern
LR
Lin Romano
google
02.26.2018
3/5

Pretty good coffee in a too-small shop with a design that accentuates the crowding. Some food available, though it's tough to enjoy a meal with people hovering for a seat or just to stay in line to order. Note: Good bagels run out early as a rule. Not many reasonable options in the area for a quick cup or to chat with someone, so it likely will remain popular. The workers are brisk and efficient. Give them a tip.

Blue Hill Tavern
LN
Lojuicestics Network
google
02.23.2018
5/5

It was relaxing and there was a nice amount of sunlight shining as I drink my peppermint tea.

Blue Hill Tavern
JB
Joshua Berg
google
02.12.2018
5/5

Love these guys! Great coffee and a great space, and the food is very reasonable

Blue Hill Tavern
DO
Diana OB
google
02.05.2018
5/5

Lovely place, good fresh food.

Blue Hill Tavern
JP
Josiah Phillips
google
02.04.2018
5/5

Great atmosphere and even better food!

Blue Hill Tavern
DL
Dana Little
google
01.18.2018
4/5

Small, crowded, we had to sit outside when we visited but the weather was pleasant and we enjoyed being outside. Nice variety of food, I had a vegetarian burrito which was excellent.

Blue Hill Tavern
EA
Emily Antonen
google
01.18.2018
5/5

Wide variety of espresso drinks. Healthy and hearty foods. Order at counter or call it in. Not a lot of indoor seating, but outdoor tables in good weather. Close to MICA.

Blue Hill Tavern
AM
ALex Marler
google
01.10.2018
1/5

TLDR: Wait time incredibly long for cafe sandwich, and sandwich not very good. Wait time for a simple sandwich was 30 mins. There were 3 employees working: 1 cooking, and the other two mostly standing around occasionally taking orders. Considering the wait times, that is backwards. By the time i was given my food, the yucca fries were soggy. The sandwich had a way too much lettuce, and the thinnest slice of cheese imaginable. The bread was not even toasted.

Blue Hill Tavern
JM
Jonathan McGeehan
google
11.25.2017
5/5

This place is hands down for me myself the best bacon cheese burger

Blue Hill Tavern
NW
Nat W
google
11.01.2017
5/5

Great little cafe. Eclectic food choices. Vegetarian options. Delicious deserts. Charming indoor and outdoor areas.

Blue Hill Tavern
JL
Jason Lunden
google
11.01.2017
5/5

This is a great indie coffee shop. In addition to the standard pastries that you would expect, they are a full restaurant with burgers and other hot food choices. I stop by whenever I am in the neighborhood.

Blue Hill Tavern
PM
Peggy Moser
google
10.18.2017
5/5

I have been getting take out from cafe on the hill for the past two years and the burgers have been a great deal for the amount of food you get. I was very sad to see them closed when COVID started. I was so excited that they have opened again but was leery of a new menu. However, the new food items are delicious! Love the burgers (smaller but still good value). I had spiral cut fries which were some of the best fries I have had in quite a while! The plantains are great too. Our most recent order had hot and crispy regular fries (very delicious) but we did miss the spirals.

Blue Hill Tavern
RR
Ro Ro
google
09.13.2017
5/5

Excellent food...pleasant atmosphere. Staff very nice & very helpful. L___aka Tuna melt was everything!! 😊 (Roc A.)

Blue Hill Tavern
AB
Arnetra Burnett
google
08.21.2017
5/5

This is my new favorite place. I go for the lemonade and sometimes I get a bite to eat. I highly recommend the Mosher with a coconut lemonade.

Blue Hill Tavern
ss
sonya schwarz
google
07.24.2017
5/5

I love these finds! This place is amazing! Small breakfast shop with excellent food and service. Bathrooms clean and ambiance cozy. Definitely worth checking out!

Blue Hill Tavern
tt
tylenol tommy
google
05.16.2017
5/5

Tamale cakes. I come from NYC to visit friends once a year and I make sure to go here at least twice a trip for tamale cakes. They're amazing. I've tried other menu items and are great as well...but those tamale cakes....

Blue Hill Tavern
KB
Keith Bennett
google
05.05.2017
5/5

Best coffeehouse on Bolton Hill. Muffins baked in-house every night. Good food. Competent friendly staff.

Blue Hill Tavern
KS
Kim Sadberry
google
04.22.2017
4/5

They would've received 5 stars, except their specialty coffee machine was broken. That being said, their regular coffee was exceptional, customer service was great, ambiance was everything I look for in a true coffee drinker's local cafe. Prices were reasonable.

Blue Hill Tavern
GM
Gregory Mcdaniel
google
04.09.2017
5/5

Good coffee and food as well, and a very cosy place.

Blue Hill Tavern
RH
Russell Hatterer
google
03.07.2017
5/5

Had the pleasure of visiting my amazing Daughter at her College during a beautiful Autumn Weekend in Baltimore! After she gave me the tour of the MICA campus, she insisted that I join her for a Coffee/Tea at her favorite lunch spot "On The Hill!" I found the Café to be very charming and absolutely loved my coffee. The staff was very nice and engaging. They have many delicious specialty Teas & hot drinks as well as sandwiches, burritos & burgers on the menu. They even have Rice & Beans and fantastic "Plantains!" Stop by, sit inside or grab a sidewalk table, order away and enjoy!

Blue Hill Tavern
FC
Faith Couch
google
01.11.2017
4/5

On the Hill Cafe stands out for it's consistent product. Unlike most places, they use grass fed beef, this sets them apart from any burger joint in the area. They always have fresh baked goods and quick service.

Blue Hill Tavern
John
google
11.24.2016
5/5

Great burgers, nice service staff, and cool decor (it's in a old rowhouse of sorts). On the downside, seating is tight, so you might have to hover a little bit to snag a seat from a brooding art student. Great neighborhood spot!

Blue Hill Tavern
AP
Audriana Page
google
11.14.2016
1/5

Usually love OTH and always get their burgers. Was excited to hear that they re-opened a few days ago. But honestly, the food was disappointing. The burger was overcooked and dry, also weirdly the buns were very squished down. Fries were limp too. Not anywhere close to being as good as before unfortunately. Not really worth it.

Blue Hill Tavern
MR
MacKenzie Rattray
google
11.07.2016
4/5

Great location, excellent place for MICA students on their way to class or for meeting up, etc. Lost a star because the food is getting increasingly expensive for less quantity. Fewer and fewer people can afford to go here as much as I'm sure they'd like to, but it is a treat to come in and get their Smokey Burger, Rutter Burrito or Tamale Cakes once in a while (my favorites, I recommend!).

Blue Hill Tavern
EO
Erik Olthof
google
10.10.2016
2/5

Ordered the lox on a bagel for pickup. The lox & other ingredients inside seemed fresh and of good quality. But the main issue was the bagel (which for a bagel with lox & cream cheese is a large part of the order) - the bagel was small, as though it was purchased from a store but, more importantly, it was either frozen and never properly warmed up or it was beyond stale because the bagel was like 2 hockey pucks. They were near inedible. I took one bite and had to transfer all of the inside ingredients to some bread I had on hand, it was so bad. $10 for a sandwich in which I had to reconstruct/replace the bagel.All in all, I would skip the bagel or anything that comes with a bagel.Reply to the response from the owner: If the quality that I received was what you can provide, I would highly suggest taking it off the menu entirely, or reducing your prices to compensate.

Blue Hill Tavern
EC
Esther Chance
google
08.16.2016
5/5

Coffee is ok. Food is greatl!

Blue Hill Tavern
GH
Geoff Huntington
google
08.05.2016
5/5

One of my favourite cafes, simply wonderful and excellent service. Look forward to coming back.

Blue Hill Tavern
KK
Kathleen Koban
google
07.08.2016
5/5

Great tasting grass fed burger with white cheddar & fries! Definitely worth the stop 😊

Blue Hill Tavern
KM
Kel Millionie
google
06.17.2016
5/5

Such a wonderful corner cafe. Fantastic food, excellent coffee beverages, and pastries to die for. Can often be overrun with art students, but ignore their hippy-like disposition and grab a table outside.

Blue Hill Tavern
RC
Ryan Clancy
google
06.01.2016
5/5

The best, any time of the day. A diverse menu and a friendly staff.

Blue Hill Tavern
KG
Karen Graveline
google
05.14.2016
5/5

Delicious breakfast sandwiches with gluten free options. Bacon was meaty and cooked to perfection. Even though it was busy on a Saturday morning, we waited less than five minutes for our order. Great for takeout which is wrapped in foil and paper bags rather than styrofoam and plastic, YAY!

Blue Hill Tavern
UC
Uni College London
google
05.10.2016
5/5

I’ve popped in for a few orders, positively ecstatic about cafe salads, too, quesadilla menu item. Prefer take away albeit it is rather quaint for a read or cheeky chats. Carry on, OHT Bolton.

Blue Hill Tavern
IB
Ian Blackwell Rogers
google
04.23.2016
5/5

Great coffee & sandwiches in Bolton Hill near MICA. I've had the cumin- crusted pork; this time it was the plantain, queso, & avocado arepa. Yum!

Blue Hill Tavern
trollbunny
google
04.10.2016
5/5

Great experience. Nice people and great food!

Blue Hill Tavern
MH
Maureen Harvie
google
03.24.2016
5/5

Best coffee in Baltimore! Their lattes are so good that I don’t even need to add sugar. Amazing sandwiches, burgers. A warm and welcoming spot!

Blue Hill Tavern
SB
Sandra B.
google
03.14.2016
1/5

On the outside it is very cute coffee shop and it had amazing reviews so I decided to try it on my travels. Unfortunately the moment I walked in, the cashier/server was not friendly at all. He also left out options I could have with my order. A bit snobby.The coffee and bagel was ehh...and it had greasy butter on it instead of serving it on the side. Overall, the coffee shop and its staff just had an unwelcoming energy I felt and will not be going back. Will go back to Baby's on Fire..lovely coffeeshop with amazing inviting energy and great coffee about 5 min away.!!

Blue Hill Tavern
SM
Sean Monroe
google
03.10.2016
5/5

The coffee and service is just right!

Blue Hill Tavern
LN
Londyn Niree
google
01.26.2016
4/5

On the hill cafe has the best fries, hands down! The service is good and although many times I wasn't allowed inside because I'm a minor, I would definitely figure out a new way to go.

Blue Hill Tavern
ZW
Zackery Wyjadka
google
01.07.2016
5/5

It's a tiny gem near MICA. The black bean burgers are as good as their coffee selection. It will be a stop on my Baltimore trips.

Blue Hill Tavern
DP
Derrick Pursoo
google
01.03.2016
5/5

This was not an easy find but personally, people should be flocking to this corner store. the cafe is not the biggest but flavor-wise and selection is perfection. they have options for all vegans, meat-eaters, health enthusiasts, and the sweet tooth. The cafe even has some ethnic dishes that I didn't expect to find. This is a place you should out on your radar for some spectacular lunch.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 14102259667

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!